EBAY (kage) vs Stores (madda) > maxminis.com- D&D minis, 4th edition D&D

Unanswered Active Topics

Forums Search

Forums > References & General Interest > Trading: References

Subject: EBAY (kage) vs Stores (madda)

You are not authorized to post a reply.

Author

Messages

Zenako
Commander

3465 Posts

05/18/2006 10:24 PM
Greetings folks. The question has been raised a few times about my general assertition about scaling of prices between EBAY and the Price Guide. Well until recently there was no easily acessible listing of EBAY pricing. A gentleman on the WotC boards - KAGE - has undertaken to compile such data. Here is what I found using the data KAGE had tabulated for the first 5 sets. I compared it to the price guide data from the same timeframe in general. (The EBAY data was collected over the span of many weeks, so it is not a "snapshot" but almost a moving average, and I have no insight into how robust or accurate the number are, but I am willing to accept them as a valid reference list for this exercise.) When comparing the total pricing for all 332 minis from the first 5 sets we find <br> EBAY %<br> EBAY Madda of madda<br>5 Set $2,234 $3,703 60%<br> When comparing the total prices of the three rarity grades on average against each other we see. `EBAY % EBAY Madda of madda Commons $86 $192 45% Rares $1,853 $3,033 61% Unc $295 $477 62%` What this shows is that the average prices for Rares and Uncommons fall into the range I have generally cited of close to 2/3 of guide prices, however the prices of commons turns out to be much lower on average. How about by Set `EBAY % EBAY Madda of madda HARBINGER $709 $1,085 65% DRAGONEYE $293 $526 56% ARCHFIENDS $542 $973 56% GIANTS of LEG $492 $753 65% ABERRATIONS $197 $364 54%` Some of those sets are dragged down by having lots of relatively worthless commons. 5 of the lowest 7 rated commons all come from the Aberrations Set. The whole data list follows below. EBAY % HARBINGER EBAY Madda madda Rarity Name DDM001001 $2.57 $3.16 81% U Cleric of Order DDM001002 $2.62 $2.87 91% U Cleric of Yondalla DDM001003 $1.06 $3.99 27% C Dwarf Axefighter DDM001004 $1.39 $3.37 41% U Ember, Human Monk DDM001005 $2.09 $3.33 63% U Evoker's Apprentice DDM001006 $2.99 $5.37 56% U Halfling Veteran DDM001007 $16.51 $28.38 58% R Hound Archon DDM001008 $1.06 $2.96 36% C Human Commoner DDM001009 $12.10 $25.42 48% R Large Earth Elemental DDM001010 $0.88 $3.24 27% C Man-at-Arms DDM001011 $2.41 $2.69 90% U Sun Soul Initiate DDM001012 $16.88 $35.68 47% R Sword of Heironeous DDM001013 $2.28 $3.99 57% U Tordek, Dwarf fighter DDM001014 $2.94 $3.49 84% U Jozan, Cleric of Pelor DDM001015 $22.07 $33.90 65% R Arcane Archer DDM001016 $2.49 $3.49 71% U Axe Sister DDM001017 $16.51 $22.88 72% R Centaur DDM001018 $14.91 $23.98 62% R Cleric of Corellon Larethian DDM001019 $1.19 $2.03 59% C Crested Felldrake DDM001020 $1.87 $3.67 51% U Devis, Half-Elf Bard DDM001021 $1.13 $2.63 43% C Elf Archer DDM001022 $35.04 $29.99 117% R Elf Pyromancer DDM001023 $1.80 $3.49 52% U Elf Ranger DDM001024 $2.60 $1.31 198% C Gnome Recruit DDM001025 $4.28 $4.66 92% U Human Wanderer DDM001026 $0.50 $3.66 14% U Krusk, Half-Orc Barbarian DDM001027 $1.74 $3.16 55% U Lidda, Halfling Rogue DDM001028 $2.93 $3.11 94% U Nebin, Gnome Illusionist DDM001029 $16.25 $21.00 77% R Vadania, Half-Elf Druid DDM001030 $3.00 $3.62 83% U Wild Elf Barbarian DDM001031 $3.12 $3.48 90% U Wood Elf Skirmisher DDM001032 $4.15 $4.99 83% U Azer Raider DDM001033 $3.00 $3.37 89% U Half-Orc Monk DDM001034 $16.59 $22.84 73% R Dire Boar DDM001035 $7.28 $5.72 127% U Lizardfolk DDM001036 $13.81 $21.78 63% R Shambling Mound DDM001037 $1.41 $4.08 35% C Wolf DDM001038 $11.42 $20.88 55% R Thri-Kreen Ranger DDM001039 $12.01 $24.11 50% R Barghest DDM001040 $16.33 $32.47 50% R Bearded Devil DDM001041 $36.01 $48.51 74% R Displacer Beast DDM001042 $1.57 $3.24 48% C Goblin Sneak DDM001043 $1.10 $1.85 59% C Half-Orc Fighter DDM001044 1.05 $2.81 37% C Hell Hound DDM001045 $23.83 $37.50 64% R Human Blackguard DDM001046 $1.45 $3.31 44% U Human Executioner DDM001047 $0.50 $3.49 14% U Human Thug DDM001048 $1.15 $2.65 43% C Kobold Warrior DDM001049 $16.92 $25.58 66% R Medusa DDM001050 $26.11 $38.89 67% R Mind Flayer DDM001051 $11.51 $24.02 48% R Mummy DDM001052 $3.09 $5.01 62% U Wight DDM001053 $24.71 $41.28 60% R Wraith DDM001054 $26.34 $37.39 70% R Owlbear DDM001055 $1.57 $3.99 39% C Skeleton DDM001056 $2.13 $4.19 51% U Troglodyte Zombie DDM001057 $1.07 $1.83 58% C Wolf Skeleton DDM001058 $1.26 $3.07 41% C Zombie DDM001059 $23.42 $36.64 64% R Cleric of Gruumsh DDM001060 $7.85 $8.03 98% U Drow Archer DDM001061 $38.28 $66.03 58% R Drow Cleric of Lolth DDM001062 $7.74 $8.48 91% U Drow Fighter DDM001063 $0.78 $3.68 21% C Ghoul DDM001064 $2.13 $5.24 41% U Gnoll DDM001065 $2.34 $2.81 83% U Half-Orc Assassin DDM001066 $1.02 $2.74 37% C Human Bandit DDM001067 $1.18 $1.87 63% C Hyena DDM001068 $3.15 $2.68 118% C Kuo-Toa DDM001069 $19.00 $28.93 66% R Large Fire Elemental DDM001070 $12.60 $27.01 47% R Minotaur DDM001071 $20.39 $30.91 66% R Ogre DDM001072 $6.65 $7.39 90% U Orc Archer DDM001073 $2.64 $6.05 44% U Orc Berserker DDM001074 $2.43 $4.43 55% C Orc Spearfighter DDM001075 $2.43 $5.61 43% C Orc Warrior DDM001076 $3.58 $4.12 87% U Tiefling Captain DDM001077 $17.83 $28.73 62% R Troll DDM001078 $56.88 $67.40 84% R Umber Hulk DDM001079 $5.59 $3.83 146% U Werewolf DDM001080 $5.13 $6.28 82% U Worg Total $709 $1,085 65% DRAGONEYE DDM002001 $0.96 $4.20 23% U Cleric of Moradin DDM002002 $7.97 $14.90 53% R Dwarven Defender DDM002003 $0.87 $1.19 73% C Gnome Fighter DDM002004 $8.23 $14.63 56% R Gold Champion DDM002005 $1.13 $2.82 40% C Human Crossbowman DDM002006 $4.49 $11.60 39% R Lion Falcon Monk DDM002007 $12.29 $16.32 75% R Purple Dragon Knight DDM002008 $1.86 $4.06 46% U Stalwart Paladin DDM002009 $0.50 $1.28 39% C Stonechild DDM002010 $0.99 $2.50 40% U Dwarven Werebear DDM002011 $10.33 $16.00 65% R Dire Lion DDM002012 $1.14 $2.49 46% U Regdar, Human Fighter DDM002013 $5.90 $12.56 47% R Bladesinger DDM002014 $13.90 $23.79 58% R Brass Dragon DDM002015 $0.55 $1.93 28% U Copper Samurai DDM002016 $0.99 $4.67 21% U Daring Rogue DDM002017 $0.80 $1.87 43% U Drunken Master DDM002018 $0.38 $1.08 35% C Dwarf Barbarian DDM002019 $0.71 $2.14 33% C Elf Spearguard DDM002020 $0.80 $2.27 35% U Half-Elf Sorcerer DDM002021 $10.59 $15.39 69% R Halfling Outrider DDM002022 $0.88 $2.23 39% U Kerwyn, Human Rogue DDM002023 $1.25 $3.25 38% U Medium Air Elemental DDM002024 $7.43 $11.99 62% R Silver Sorcerer DDM002025 $0.63 $2.09 30% C Barbarian Mercenary DDM002026 $8.03 $12.59 64% R Dire Ape DDM002027 $2.65 $2.85 93% U Druid of Obad-Hai DDM002028 $2.06 $2.47 83% C Baaz Draconian DDM002029 $3.13 $5.69 55% U Blue Wyrmling DDM002030 $1.95 $7.16 27% U Cleric of Nerull DDM002031 $1.13 $4.73 24% C Goblin Skirmisher DDM002032 $1.11 $3.52 32% C Goblin Warrior DDM002033 $1.83 $2.78 66% C Hobgoblin Warrior DDM002034 $3.99 $5.98 67% U Kapak Draconian DDM002035 $1.11 $1.98 56% C Kobold Skirmisher DDM002036 $0.78 $3.19 24% U Medium Water Elemental DDM002037 $7.72 $17.49 44% R Salamander DDM002038 $9.90 $13.99 71% R Thayan Knight DDM002039 $3.31 $2.62 126% U Urthok the Vicious DDM002040 $1.95 $4.49 43% U Wererat DDM002041 $7.96 $16.35 49% R Carrion Crawler DDM002042 $0.75 $1.39 54% C Grimlock DDM002043 $0.94 $1.61 58% C Abyssal Maw DDM002044 $18.29 $26.05 70% R Black Dragon DDM002045 $5.84 $14.05 42% R Bright Naga DDM002046 $1.15 $2.70 43% C Bugbear DDM002047 $0.79 $2.99 26% U Chitine DDM002048 $0.60 $1.31 46% C Dretch DDM002049 $3.14 $6.25 50% U Drow Warrior DDM002050 $4.51 $8.50 53% U Drow Wizard DDM002051 $16.40 $21.33 77% Eye of Gruumsh DDM002052 $2.58 $3.79 68% U Gargoyle DDM002053 $3.49 $5.24 67% U Harpy DDM002054 $12.44 $37.94 33% R Large Monstrous Spider DDM002055 $35.43 $56.66 63% R Large Red Dragon DDM002056 $14.70 $25.02 59% R Ogre Ravager DDM002057 $8.52 $15.79 54% R Orc Druid DDM002058 $4.15 $3.75 111% U Red Samurai DDM002059 $3.98 $5.13 78% U Small White Dragon DDM002060 $1.47 $2.03 72% C Troglodyte Total $293 $526 56% ARCHFIENDS DDM003001 $2.77 $3.83 72% U Cleric of Lathander DDM003002 $1.18 $2.59 46% C Dalelands Militia DDM003003 $2.73 $4.24 64% U Gold Dwarf Fighter DDM003004 $5.71 $4.00 143% U Human Dragonslayer DDM003005 $56.45 $85.00 66% R Large Silver Dragon DDM003006 $1.75 $3.72 47% U Medium Earth Elemental DDM003007 $9.63 $16.45 59% R Paladin of Torm DDM003008 $0.87 $3.33 26% C Soldier of Cormyr DDM003009 $1.68 $4.11 41% U Healer DDM003010 $2.44 $4.49 54% U Mialee, Elf Wizard DDM003011 $0.66 $1.74 38% C Catfolk DDM003012 $32.01 $50.00 64% R Champion of Eilistraee DDM003013 $1.61 $3.07 52% U Cleric of Kord DDM003014 $84.76 $140.00 61% R Drizzt, Drow Ranger DDM003015 $2.34 $6.83 34% U Evermeet Wizard DDM003016 $2.22 $4.59 48% C Graycloak Ranger DDM003017 $4.99 $4.68 107% U Halfling Ranger DDM003018 $3.25 $4.17 78% U Halfling Wizard DDM003019 $2.50 $3.25 77% U Ialdabode, Human Psion DDM003020 $4.35 $5.07 86% U Moon Elf Fighter DDM003021 $2.51 $4.00 63% U Ragnara, Psychic Warrior DDM003022 $13.17 $38.57 34% R Unicorn DDM003023 $1.35 $1.60 84% C Githzerai DDM003024 $1.02 $1.62 63% C Sage DDM003025 $12.58 $30.20 42% R Clay Golem DDM003026 $1.27 $4.37 29% U Half-Orc Barbarian DDM003027 $0.91 $3.50 26% U Wereboar DDM003028 $12.70 $21.33 60% R Aspect of Bane DDM003029 $14.71 $28.82 51% R Bone Devil DDM003030 $1.43 $4.70 30% U Dark Moon Monk DDM003031 $2.38 $5.39 44% C Dread Guard DDM003032 $1.75 $3.34 52% C Duergar Warrior DDM003033 $15.60 $24.19 64% R Erinyes DDM003034 $31.12 $51.66 60% R Gauth DDM003035 $6.30 $17.01 37% R Human Cleric of Bane DDM003036 $1.08 $3.95 27% U Nothic DDM003037 $17.15 $30.14 57% R Red Wizard DDM003038 $0.83 $2.01 41% C Snig the Axe DDM003039 $1.68 $3.16 53% U Xill DDM003040 $0.96 $3.02 32% C Zhentarim Fighter DDM003041 $1.21 $2.06 59% C Gravehound DDM003042 $9.25 $23.49 39% R Ochre Jelly DDM003043 $1.79 $4.64 39% C Warrior Skeleton DDM003044 $2.43 $5.00 49% U Abyssal Eviscerator DDM003045 $12.45 $21.51 58% R Aspect of Demogorgon DDM003046 $25.55 $50.00 51% R Aspect of Lolth DDM003047 $21.92 $45.00 49% R Aspect of Orcus DDM003048 $1.06 $2.17 49% C Cultist of the Dragon DDM003049 $1.32 $4.26 31% C Cursed Spirit DDM003050 $9.06 $8.79 103% U Drow Sergeant DDM003051 $3.25 $4.50 72% U Githyanki Fighter DDM003052 $1.13 $3.17 36% C Gnoll Archer DDM003053 $13.67 $33.84 40% R Hill Giant DDM003054 $3.00 $4.62 65% U Medium Fire Elemental DDM003055 $30.84 $47.99 64% R Orc Champion DDM003056 $1.18 $3.05 39% C Orc Raider DDM003057 $12.15 $27.20 45% R Vampire Aristocrat DDM003058 $21.47 $30.86 70% R Vrock DDM003059 $3.84 $8.98 43% U Young Minotaur DDM003060 $1.50 $4.50 33% U Yuan-Ti Pureblood Total $542 $973 56% GIANTS OF LEGEND DDM004001 $1.33 $3.67 36% U Bronze Wyrmling DDM004002 $1.30 $2.00 65% U Dwarf Sergeant DDM004003 $0.84 $1.37 61% U Standardbearer DDM004004 $8.96 $17.56 51% R Stone Golem DDM004005 $1.23 $2.08 59% U Sword of Glory DDM004006 $2.45 $3.71 66% U Warforged Fighter DDM004007 $1.11 $1.68 66% U Warmage DDM004008 $6.42 $14.58 44% R Young Master DDM004009 $0.69 $1.67 41% U Aramil, Adventurer DDM004010 $1.00 $1.76 57% U Eberk, Adventurer DDM004011 $1.05 $1.80 58% U Protectar DDM004012 $1.19 $2.12 56% U Regdar, Adventurer DDM004013 $0.99 $2.35 42% U Basilisk DDM004014 $0.89 $3.29 27% U Deepshadow Elf DM004015 $4.83 $10.51 46% R Fire Genasi Dervish DDM004016 $7.09 $11.57 61% R Githyanki Renegade DDM004017 $4.08 $13.42 30% R Half-Giant Psychic Warrior DDM004018 $6.19 $12.70 49% R Inspiring Marshal DDM004019 $1.12 $1.42 79% U Lidda, Adventurer DDM004020 $0.42 $0.88 48% C Medium Astral Construct DDM004021 $2.58 $9.89 26% R War Chanter DDM004022 $0.99 $1.50 66% U Xeph Soulknife DDM004023 $1.00 $1.85 54% C City Guard DDM004024 $0.58 $1.52 38% U Crucian DDM004025 $9.38 $18.00 52% R Dire Wolf DDM004026 $24.57 $28.94 85% R Mordenkainen the Mage DDM004027 $10.25 $14.59 70% R Otyugh DDM004028 $0.59 $1.16 51% C Bladeling Fighter DDM004029 $0.56 $0.95 59% C Blue DDM004030 $1.01 $3.15 32% C Dire Rat DDM004031 $17.12 $25.92 66% R Fire Giant DDM004032 $1.03 $2.49 41% C Hobgoblin Sergeant DDM004033 $15.17 $19.83 77% R King Snurre DDM004034 $0.74 $1.31 56% C Lemure DDM004035 $0.55 $2.21 25% C Lizardfolk Rogue DDM004036 $27.13 $29.90 91% R Lord Soth DDM004037 $11.95 $17.04 70% R Manticore DDM004038 $9.52 $20.60 46% R Rakshasa DDM004039 $0.99 $1.99 50% U Scarlet Brotherhood Monk DDM004040 $0.89 $1.90 47% C Zombie DDM004041 $13.11 $19.28 68% R Blue Slaad DDM004042 $1.17 $2.37 49% C Bugbear Footpad DDM004043 $0.68 $1.09 62% C Displacer Serpent DDM004044 $23.08 $29.65 78% R Drider Sorcerer DDM004045 $3.76 $5.84 64% U Drow Fighter DDM004046 $1.98 $3.26 61% U Drow Rogue DDM004047 $0.81 $1.22 66% C Ettercap DDM004048 $17.10 $27.65 62% R Frost Giant DDM004049 $0.81 $1.55 52% C Ghast DDM004050 $0.94 $2.27 41% U Gnoll Sergeant DDM004051 $1.11 $1.17 95% C Grick DDM004052 $3.49 $14.28 24% R Lareth the Beautiful DDM004053 $12.96 $21.77 60% R Lich Necromancer DDM004054 $9.27 $14.95 62% R Minotaur DDM004055 $6.32 $12.31 51% R Minotaur Skeleton DDM004056 $0.67 $1.44 47% C Orc Brute DDM004057 $1.60 $2.84 56% U Quasit DDM004058 $13.71 $15.46 89% R Red Dragon Wyrmling DDM004059 $0.53 $1.07 50% C Tanarukk DDM004060 $1.71 $2.68 64% U Werewolf DDM004061 $46.64 $62.47 75% RH Huge Gold Dragon DDM004062 $5.29 $5.92 89% UH Cloud Giant DDM004063 $12.45 $16.64 75% RH Storm Giant DDM004064 $3.43 $7.53 46% UH Treant DDM004065 $15.72 $19.91 79% RH Warforged Titan DDM004066 $17.96 $26.76 67% RH Behir DDM004067 $4.60 $6.34 73% UH Bulette DDM004068 $2.42 $5.71 42% UH Fiendish Tyrannosaurus DDM004069 $2.67 $7.22 37% UH Fomorian DDM004070 $14.53 $24.14 60% RH Glabrezu DDM004071 $59.13 $67.47 88% RH Huge Red Dragon DDM004072 $2.62 $6.20 42% UH Nightwalker Total $492 $753 65% ABERRATIONS DDM005001 $4.89 $9.66 51% R Alusair Obarskyr DDM005002 $0.79 $1.18 67% U Anvil of Thunder DDM005003 $0.32 $0.70 46% C Celestial Black Bear DDM005004 $1.73 $2.95 59% U Cleric of St. Cuthbert DDM005005 $5.93 $10.88 55% R Dragon Samurai DDM005006 $3.70 $9.35 40% R Exorcist of the Silver Flame DDM005007 $0.30 $2.48 12% C Hill Dwarf Warrior DDM005008 $0.24 $2.07 12% C Man-at-Arms DDM005009 $0.84 $1.31 64% U Rhek DDM005010 $9.58 $17.21 56% R Warforged Hero DDM005011 $1.19 $1.23 97% U Aasimar Favored Soul DDM005012 $5.46 $10.65 51% R Adventuring Wizard DDM005013 $1.41 $1.45 97% U Bariaur Ranger DDM005014 $1.53 $1.31 117% U Cleric of Garl Glittergold DDM005015 $5.45 $10.06 54% R Crow Shaman DDM005016 $0.37 $2.10 18% C Elf Warrior DDM005017 $10.92 $18.55 59% R Frenzied Berserker DDM005018 $8.08 $14.35 56% R Half-Elf Bow Initiate DDM005019 $0.75 $1.59 47% U Longtooth Barbarian DDM005020 $0.84 $2.03 41% U Sharn Cutthroat DDM005021 $3.49 $9.24 38% R Valenar Commander DDM005022 $0.78 $1.93 40% U Formian Warrior DDM005023 $0.50 $1.17 43% U Ethereal Filcher DDM005024 $7.57 $15.06 50% R Ryld Argith DDM005025 $12.90 $18.52 70% R Wyvern DDM005026 $5.50 $10.37 53% R Achaierai DDM005027 $1.31 $1.71 77% U Bladebearer Hobgoblin DDM005028$0.33 $0.90 37% C Dekanter Goblin DDM005029 $1.05 $1.76 60% U Destrachan DDM005030 $0.84 $1.46 58% C Emerald Claw Soldier DDM005031 $0.22 $0.83 27% C Fiendish Dire Weasel DDM005032 $13.19 $21.88 60% R Green Dragon DDM005033 $0.83 $1.95 43% U Half-Elf Hexblade DDM005034 $1.43 $1.55 92% U Half-Illithid Lizardfolk DDM005035 $7.55 $13.81 55% R Hook Horror DDM005036 $1.31 $1.33 98% U Iron Cobra DDM005037 $1.11 $1.68 66% C Kobold Champion DDM005038 $1.02 $1.73 59% U Kobold Sorcerer DDM005039 $14.76 $19.29 77% R Mind Flayer Telepath DDM005040 $0.24 $0.87 28% C Mongrelfolk DDM005041 $0.61 $1.03 59% C Myconid Guard DDM005042 $0.76 $2.72 28% U Sahuagin Ranger DDM005043 $0.26 $1.23 21% C Silent Wolf Goblin DDM005044 $2.97 $9.75 30% R Skullsplitter DDM005045 $5.46 $12.17 45% R Flesh Golem DDM005046 $0.34 $0.83 41% C Carrion Tribe Barbarian DDM005047 $0.77 $1.34 57% U Choker DDM005048 $7.62 $12.96 59% R Chuul DDM005049 $4.33 $10.93 40% R Fiendish Giant Praying Mantis DDM005050 $5.88 $10.06 58% R Gibbering Mouther DDM005051 $0.87 $2.49 35% C Gnoll DDM005052 $0.36 $1.24 29% C Gnoll Skeleton DDM005053 $6.67 $13.76 48% R Ice Troll DDM005054 $0.57 $1.76 32% U Mad Slasher DDM005055 $0.65 $1.58 41% C Mountain Orc DDM005056 $6.95 $9.69 72% R Ogre Zombie DDM005057 $0.75 $2.70 28% U Orc Sergeant DDM005058 $0.24 $0.98 24% C Taer DDM005059 $9.55 $17.56 54% R Yuan-Ti Abomination DDM005060 $1.52 $1.93 79% U Yuan-Ti Halfblood Total $197 $364 54% A close look will reveal several minis that would have been cheaper to purchase from stores than on EBAY. This is not surprising since most buyers do not have perfect knowledge of the market. Hopefully this comparitive exercise will address the questions that were raised. I will leave this stickied for a few days, then let it slide.

Built the addition for this addiction, now on to the "gaming table" project.... http://www.maxminis.com/hw_list.asp?user=Zenako last updated 29 May 2006 Set Status: in a nutshell = all of all In Process trades0), (Sig last updated 05/29/06) 300 plus Completed Trades - If I seem scarce at times...blame DDO - Sarlona

Zenako
Commander

3465 Posts

05/18/2006 10:30 PM
Now sorted by rarity class and price ratio: <br> EBAY %<br>HARBINGER EBAY Madda madda Rarity Name<br>DDM005008 $0.24 $2.07 12% C Man-at-Arms<br>DDM005007 $0.30 $2.48 12% C Hill Dwarf Warrior<br>DDM005016 $0.37 $2.10 18% C Elf Warrior<br>DDM005043 $0.26 $1.23 21% C Silent Wolf Goblin<br>DDM001063 $0.78 $3.68 21% C Ghoul<br>DDM002031 $1.13 $4.73 24% C Goblin Skirmisher<br>DDM005058 $0.24 $0.98 24% C Taer<br>DDM004035 $0.55 $2.21 25% C Lizardfolk Rogue<br>DDM003008 $0.87 $3.33 26% C Soldier of Cormyr<br>DDM005031 $0.22 $0.83 27% C Fiendish Dire Weasel<br>DDM001003 $1.06 $3.99 27% C Dwarf Axefighter<br>DDM001010 $0.88 $3.24 27% C Man-at-Arms<br>DDM005040 $0.24 $0.87 28% C Mongrelfolk<br>DDM005052 $0.36 $1.24 29% C Gnoll Skeleton<br>DDM002025 $0.63 $2.09 30% C Barbarian Mercenary<br>DDM003049 $1.32 $4.26 31% C Cursed Spirit<br>DDM002032 $1.11 $3.52 32% C Goblin Warrior<br>DDM003040 $0.96 $3.02 32% C Zhentarim Fighter<br>DDM004030 $1.01 $3.15 32% C Dire Rat<br>DDM002019 $0.71 $2.14 33% C Elf Spearguard<br>DDM001037 $1.41 $4.08 35% C Wolf<br>DDM005051 $0.87 $2.49 35% C Gnoll<br>DDM002018 $0.38 $1.08 35% C Dwarf Barbarian<br>DDM003052 $1.13 $3.17 36% C Gnoll Archer<br>DDM001008 $1.06 $2.96 36% C Human Commoner<br>DDM005028 $0.33 $0.90 37% C Dekanter Goblin<br>DDM001066 $1.02 $2.74 37% C Human Bandit<br>DDM001044 $1.05 $2.81 37% C Hell Hound<br>DDM003011 $0.66 $1.74 38% C Catfolk<br>DDM003043 $1.79 $4.64 39% C Warrior Skeleton<br>DDM003056 $1.18 $3.05 39% C Orc Raider<br>DDM002009 $0.50 $1.28 39% C Stonechild<br>DDM001055 $1.57 $3.99 39% C Skeleton<br>DDM002005 $1.13 $2.82 40% C Human Crossbowman<br>DDM005046 $0.34 $0.83 41% C Carrion Tribe Barbarian<br>DDM001058 $1.26 $3.07 41% C Zombie<br>DDM005055 $0.65 $1.58 41% C Mountain Orc<br>DDM003038 $0.83 $2.01 41% C Snig the Axe<br>DDM004032 $1.03 $2.49 41% C Hobgoblin Sergeant<br>DDM002046 $1.15 $2.70 43% C Bugbear<br>DDM001021 $1.13 $2.63 43% C Elf Archer<br>DDM001075 $2.43 $5.61 43% C Orc Warrior<br>DDM001048 $1.15 $2.65 43% C Kobold Warrior<br>DDM003031 $2.38 $5.39 44% C Dread Guard<br>DDM003002 $1.18 $2.59 46% C Dalelands Militia<br>DDM005003 $0.32 $0.70 46% C Celestial Black Bear<br>DDM002048 $0.60 $1.31 46% C Dretch<br>DDM004056 $0.67 $1.44 47% C Orc Brute<br>DDM004040 $0.89 $1.90 47% C Zombie<br>DDM004020 $0.42 $0.88 48% C Medium Astral Construct<br>DDM003016 $2.22 $4.59 48% C Graycloak Ranger<br>DDM001042 $1.57 $3.24 48% C Goblin Sneak<br>DDM003048 $1.06 $2.17 49% C Cultist of the Dragon<br>DDM004042 $1.17 $2.37 49% C Bugbear Footpad<br>DDM004059 $0.53 $1.07 50% C Tanarukk<br>DDM004028 $0.59 $1.16 51% C Bladeling Fighter<br>DDM004049 $0.81 $1.55 52% C Ghast<br>DDM003032 $1.75 $3.34 52% C Duergar Warrior<br>DDM002042 $0.75 $1.39 54% C Grimlock<br>DDM004023 $1.00 $1.85 54% C City Guard<br>DDM001074 $2.43 $4.43 55% C Orc Spearfighter<br>DDM002035 $1.11 $1.98 56% C Kobold Skirmisher<br>DDM004034 $0.74 $1.31 56% C Lemure<br>DDM005030 $0.84 $1.46 58% C Emerald Claw Soldier<br>DDM002043 $0.94 $1.61 58% C Abyssal Maw<br>DDM001057 $1.07 $1.83 58% C Wolf Skeleton<br>DDM001019 $1.19 $2.03 59% C Crested Felldrake<br>DDM003041 $1.21 $2.06 59% C Gravehound<br>DDM004029 $0.56 $0.95 59% C Blue<br>DDM005041 $0.61 $1.03 59% C Myconid Guard<br>DDM001043 $1.10 $1.85 59% C Half-Orc Fighter<br>DDM004043 $0.68 $1.09 62% C Displacer Serpent<br>DDM003024 $1.02 $1.62 63% C Sage<br>DDM001067 $1.18 $1.87 63% C Hyena<br>DDM002033 $1.83 $2.78 66% C Hobgoblin Warrior<br>DDM005037 $1.11 $1.68 66% C Kobold Champion<br>DDM004047 $0.81 $1.22 66% C Ettercap<br>DDM002060 $1.47 $2.03 72% C Troglodyte<br>DDM002003 $0.87 $1.19 73% C Gnome Fighter<br>DDM002028 $2.06 $2.47 83% C Baaz Draconian<br>DDM003023 $1.35 $1.60 84% C Githzerai<br>DDM004051 $1.11 $1.17 95% C Grick<br>DDM001068 $3.15 $2.68 118% C Kuo-Toa<br>DDM001024 $2.60 $1.31 198% C Gnome Recruit<br>Commons $86.24 $192.67 45%<br> <br>DDM004052 $3.49 $14.28 24% R Lareth the Beautiful<br>DDM004021 $2.58 $9.89 26% R War Chanterbr>DDM004017 $4.08 $13.42 30% R Half-Giant Psychic Warrior<br>DDM005044 $2.97 $9.75 30% R Skullsplitter<br>DDM002054 $12.44 $37.94 33% R Large Monstrous Spider<br>DDM003022 $13.17 $38.57 34% R Unicorn<br>DDM003035 $6.30 $17.01 37% R Human Cleric of Bane<br>DDM005021 $3.49 $9.24 38% R Valenar Commander<br>DDM002006 $4.49 $11.60 39% R Lion Falcon Monk<br>DDM003042 $9.25 $23.49 39% R Ochre Jelly<br>DDM005006 $3.70 $9.35 40% R Exorcist of the Silver Flame<br>DDM005049 $4.33 $10.93 40% R Fiendish Giant Praying Mantis<br>DDM003053 $13.67 $33.84 40% R Hill Giant<br>DDM002045 $5.84 $14.05 42% R Bright Naga<br>DDM003025 $12.58 $30.20 42% R Clay Golem<br>DDM004008 $6.42 $14.58 44% R Young Master<br>DDM002037 $7.72 $17.49 44% R Salamander<br>DDM003057 $12.15 $27.20 45% R Vampire Aristocrat<br>DDM005045 $5.46 $12.17 45% R Flesh Golem<br>DDM004015 $4.83 $10.51 46% R Fire Genasi Dervish<br>DDM004038 $9.52 $20.60 46% R Rakshasa<br>DDM001070 $12.60 $27.01 47% R Minotaur<br>DDM002013 $5.90 $12.56 47% R Bladesinger<br>DDM001012 $16.88 $35.68 47% R Sword of Heironeous<br>DDM001009 $12.10 $25.42 48% R Large Earth Elemental<br>DDM001051 $11.51 $24.02 48% R Mummy<br>DDM005053 $6.67 $13.76 48% R Ice Troll<br>DDM002041 $7.96 $16.35 49% R Carrion Crawler<br>DDM003047 $21.92 $45.00 49% R Aspect of Orcus<br>DDM004018 $6.19 $12.70 49% R Inspiring Marshal<br>DDM001039 $12.01 $24.11 50% R Barghest<br>DDM005024 $7.57 $15.06 50% R Ryld Argith<br>DDM001040 $16.33 $32.47 50% R Bearded Devil<br>DDM005001 $4.89 $9.66 51% R Alusair Obarskyr<br>DDM004004 $8.96 $17.56 51% R Stone Golem<br>DDM003029 $14.71 $28.82 51% R Bone Devil<br>DDM003046 $25.55 $50.00 51% R Aspect of Lolth<br>DDM005012 $5.46 $10.65 51% R Adventuring Wizard<br>DDM004055 $6.32 $12.31 51% R Minotaur Skeleton<br>DDM004025 $9.38 $18.00 52% R Dire Wolf<br>DDM005026 $5.50 $10.37 53% R Achaierai<br>DDM002002 $7.97 $14.90 53% R Dwarven Defender<br>DDM002057 $8.52 $15.79 54% R Orc Druid<br>DDM005015 $5.45 $10.06 54% R Crow Shaman<br>DDM005059 $9.55 $17.56 54% R Yuan-Ti Abomination<br>DDM005005 $5.93 $10.88 55% R Dragon Samurai<br>DDM005035 $7.55 $13.81 55% R Hook Horror<br>DDM001038 $11.42 $20.88 55% R Thri-Kreen Ranger<br>DDM005010 $9.58 $17.21 56% R Warforged Hero<br>DDM002004 $8.23 $14.63 56% R Gold Champion<br>DDM005018 $8.08 $14.35 56% R Half-Elf Bow Initiate<br>DDM003037 $17.15 $30.14 57% R Red Wizard<br>DDM003045 $12.45 $21.51 58% R Aspect of Demogorgon<br>DDM001061 $38.28 $66.03 58% R Drow Cleric of Lolth<br>DDM001007 $16.51 $28.38 58% R Hound Archon<br>DDM002014 $13.90 $23.79 58% R Brass Dragon<br>DDM005050 $5.88 $10.06 58% R Gibbering Mouther<br>DDM003007 $9.63 $16.45 59% R Paladin of Torm<br>DDM002056 $14.70 $25.02 59% R Ogre Ravager<br>DDM005048 $7.62 $12.96 59% R Chuul<br>DDM005017 $10.92 $18.55 59% R Frenzied Berserker<br>DDM004053 $12.96 $21.77 60% R Lich Necromancer<br>DDM003028 $12.70 $21.33 60% R Aspect of Bane<br>DDM001053 $24.71 $41.28 60% R Wraith<br>DDM004070 $14.53 $24.14 60% RH Glabrezu<br>DDM003034 $31.12 $51.66 60% R Gauth<br>DDM005032 $13.19 $21.88 60% R Green Dragon<br>DDM003014 $84.76 $140.00 61% R Drizzt, Drow Ranger<br>DDM004016 $7.09 $11.57 61% R Githyanki Renegade<br>DDM004048 $17.10 $27.65 62% R Frost Giant<br>DDM002024 $7.43 $11.99 62% R Silver Sorcerer<br>DDM004054 $9.27 $14.95 62% R Minotaur<br>DDM001077 $17.83 $28.73 62% R Troll<br>DDM001018 $14.91 $23.98 62% R Cleric of Corellon Larethian<br>DDM002055 $35.43 $56.66 63% R Large Red Dragon<br>DDM001036 $13.81 $21.78 63% R Shambling Mound<br>DDM001045 $23.83 $37.50 64% R Human Blackguard<br>DDM002026 $8.03 $12.59 64% R Dire Ape<br>DDM001059 $23.42 $36.64 64% R Cleric of Gruumsh<br>DDM003012 $32.01 $50.00 64% R Champion of Eilistraee<br>DDM003055 $30.84 $47.99 64% R Orc Champion<br>DDM003033 $15.60 $24.19 64% R Erinyes<br>DDM002011 $10.33 $16.00 65% R Dire Lion<br>DDM001015 $22.07 $33.90 65% R Arcane Archer<br>DDM001069 $19.00 $28.93 66% R Large Fire Elemental<br>DDM001071 $20.39 $30.91 66% R Ogre<br>DDM004031 $17.12 $2.92 66% R Fire Giant<br>DDM001049 $16.92 $25.58 66% R Medusa<br>DDM003005 $56.45 $85.00 66% R Large Silver Dragon<br>DDM004066 $17.96 $26.76 67% RH Behir<br>DDM001050 $26.11 $38.89 67% R Mind Flayer<br>DDM004041 $13.11 $19.28 68% R Blue Slaad<br>DDM002021 $10.59 $15.39 69% R Halfling Outrider<br>DDM003058 $21.47 $30.86 70% R Vrock<br>DDM005025 $12.90 $18.52 70% R Wyvern<br>DDM004037 $11.95 $17.04 70% R Manticore<br>DDM002044 $18.29 $26.05 70% R Black Dragon<br>DDM004027 $10.25 $14.59 70% R Otyugh<br>DDM001054 $26.34 $37.39 70% R Owlbear<br>DDM002038 $9.90 $13.99 71% R Thayan Knight<br>DDM005056 $6.95 $9.69 72% R Ogre Zombie<br>DDM001017 $16.51 $22.88 72% R Centaur<br>DDM001034 $16.59 $22.84 73% R Dire Boar<br>DDM001041 $36.01 $48.51 74% R Displacer Beast<br>DDM004061 $46.64 $62.47 75% RH Huge Gold Dragon<br>DDM004063 $12.45 $16.64 75% RH Storm Giant<br>DDM002007 $12.29 $16.32 75% R Purple Dragon Knight<br>DDM004033 $15.17 $19.83 77% R King Snurre<br>DDM005039 $14.76 $19.29 77% R Mind Flayer Telepath<br>DDM002051 $16.40 $21.33 77% R Eye of Gruumsh<br>DDM001029 $16.25 $21.00 77% R Vadania, Half-Elf Druid<br>DDM004044 $23.08 $29.65 78% R Drider Sorcerer<br>DDM004065 $15.72 $19.91 79% RH Warforged Titan<br>DDM001078 $56.88 $67.40 84% R Umber Hulk<br>DDM004026 $24.57 $28.94 85% R Mordenkainen the Mage<br>DDM004071 $59.13 $67.47 88% RH Huge Red Dragon<br>DDM004058 $13.71 $15.46 89% R Red Dragon Wyrmling<br>DDM004036 $27.13 $29.90 91% R Lord Soth<br>DDM001022 $35.04 $29.99 117% R Elf Pyromancer<br>Rares $1,853 $3,033 61%<br> <br>DDM001026 $0.50 $3.66 14% U Krusk, Half-Orc Barbarian<br>DDM001047 $0.50 $3.49 14% U Human Thug<br>DDM002016 $0.99 $4.67 21% U Daring Rogue<br>DDM002001 $0.96 $4.20 23% U Cleric of Moradin<br>DDM002036 $0.78 $3.19 24% U Medium Water Elemental<br>DDM003027 $0.91 $3.50 26% U Wereboar<br>DDM002047 $0.79 $2.99 26% U Chitine<br>DDM004014 $0.89 $3.29 27% U Deepshadow Elf<br>DDM002030 $1.95 $7.16 27% U Cleric of Nerull<br>DDM003036 $1.08 $3.95 27% U Nothic<br>DDM005057 $0.75 $2.70 28% U Orc Sergeant<br>DDM005042 $0.76 $2.72 28% U Sahuagin Ranger<br>DDM002015 $0.55 $1.93 28% U Copper Samurai<br>DDM003026 $1.27 $4.37 29% U Half-Orc Barbarian<br>DDM003030 $1.43 $4.70 30% U Dark Moon Monk<br>DDM005054 $0.57 $1.76 32% U Mad Slasher<br>DDM003060 $1.50 $4.50 33% U Yuan-Ti Pureblood<br>DDM003015 $2.34 $6.83 34% U Evermeet Wizard<br>DDM002020 $0.80 $2.27 35% U Half-Elf Sorcerer<br>DDM004001 $1.33 $3.67 36% U Bronze Wyrmling<br>DDM004069 $2.67 $7.22 37% UH Fomorian<br>DDM004024 $0.58 $1.52 38% U Crucian<br>DDM002023 $1.25 $3.25 38% U Medium Air Elemental<br>DDM002022 $0.88 $2.23 39% U Kerwyn, Human Rogue<br>DDM002010 $0.99 $2.50 40% U Dwarven Werebear<br>DDM005022 $0.78 $1.93 40% U Formian Warrior<br>DDM001064 $2.13 $5.24 41% U Gnoll<br>DDM003009 $1.68 $4.11 41% U Healer<br>DDM001004 $1.39 $3.37 41% U Ember, Human Monk<br>DDM004009 $0.69 $1.67 41% U Aramil, Adventurer<br>DDM005020 $0.84 $2.03 41% U Sharn Cutthroat<br>DDM004050 $0.94 $2.27 41% U Gnoll Sergeant<br>DDM004013 $0.99 $2.35 42% U Basilisk<br>DDM004072 $2.62 $6.20 42% UH Nightwalker<br>DDM004068 $2.42 $5.71 42% UH Fiendish Tyrannosaurus<br>DDM005033 $0.83 $1.95 43% U Half-Elf Hexblade<br>DDM005023 $0.50 $1.17 43% U Ethereal Filcher<br>DDM003059 $3.84 $8.98 43% U Young Minotaur<br>DDM002017 $0.80 $1.87 43% U Drunken Master<br>DDM002040 $1.95 $4.49 43% U Wererat<br>DDM001073 $2.64 $6.05 44% U Orc Berserker<br>DDM001046 $1.45 $3.31 44% U Human Executioner<br>DDM004064 $3.43 $7.53 46% UH Treant<br>DDM002012 $1.14 $2.49 46% U Regdar, Human Fighter<br>DDM002008 $1.86 $4.06 46% U Stalwart Paladin<br>DDM003006 $1.75 $3.72 47% U Medium Earth Elemental<br>DDM005019 $0.75 $1.59 47% U Longtooth Barbarian<br>DDM003044 $2.43 $5.00 49% U Abyssal Eviscerator<br>DDM004039 $0.99 $1.99 50% U Scarlet Brotherhood Monk<br>DDM002049 $3.14 $6.25 50% U Drow Warrior<br>DDM001056 $2.13 $4.19 51% U Troglodyte Zombie<br>DDM001020 $1.87 $3.67 51% U Devis, Half-Elf Bard<br>DDM001023 $.80 $3.49 52% U Elf Ranger<br>DDM003013 $1.61 $3.07 52% U Cleric of Kord<br>DDM002050 $4.51 $8.50 53% U Drow Wizard<br>DDM003039 $1.68 $3.16 53% U Xill<br>DDM003010 $2.44 $4.49 54% U Mialee, Elf Wizard<br>DDM002029 $3.13 $5.69 55% U Blue Wyrmling<br>DDM001027 $1.74 $3.16 55% U Lidda, Halfling Rogue<br>DDM001006 $2.99 $5.37 56% U Halfling Veteran<br>DDM004012 $1.19 $2.12 56% U Regdar, Adventurer<br>DDM004057 $1.60 $2.84 56% U Quasit<br>DDM004010 $1.00 $1.76 57% U Eberk, Adventurer<br>DDM001013 $2.28 $3.99 57% U Tordek, Dwarf fighter<br>DDM005047 $0.77 $1.34 57% U Choker<br>DDM004011 $1.05 $1.80 58% U Protectar<br>DDM005004 $1.73 $2.95 59% U Cleric of St. Cuthbert<br>DDM005038 $1.02 $1.73 59% U Kobold Sorcerer<br>DDM004005 $1.23 $2.08 59% U Sword of Glory<br>DDM005029 $1.05 $1.76 60% U Destrachan<br>DDM004046 $1.98 $3.26 61% U Drow Rogue<br>DDM004003 $0.84 $1.37 61% U Standardbearer<br>DDM001052 $3.09 $5.01 62% U Wight<br>DDM003021 $2.51 $4.00 63% U Ragnara, Psychic Warrior<br>DDM001005 $2.09 $3.33 63% U Evoker's Apprentice<br>DDM004060 $1.71 $2.68 64% U Werewolf<br>DDM005009 $0.84 $1.31 64% U Rhek<br>DDM004045 $3.76 $5.84 64% U Drow Fighter<br>DDM003003 $2.73 $4.24 64% U Gold Dwarf Fighter<br>DDM003054 $3.00 $4.62 65% U Medium Fire Elemental<br>DDM004002 $1.30 $2.00 65% U Dwarf Sergeant<br>DDM004022 $0.99 $1.50 66% U Xeph Soulknife<br>DDM004006 $2.45 $3.71 66% U Warforged Fighter<br>DDM004007 $1.11 $1.68 66% U Warmage<br>DDM002053 $3.49 $5.24 67% U Harpy<br>DDM002034 $3.99 $5.98 67% U Kapak Draconian<br>DDM005002 $0.79 $1.18 67% U Anvil of Thunder<br>DDM002052 $2.58 $3.79 68% U Gargoyle<br>DDM001016 $2.49 $3.49 71% U Axe Sister<br>DDM003051 $3.25 $4.50 72% U Githyanki Fighter<br>DDM003001 $2.77 $3.83 72% U Cleric of Lathander<br>DDM004067 $4.60 $6.34 73% UH Bulette<br>DDM005027 $1.31 $1.71 77% U Bladebearer Hobgoblin<br>DDM003019 $2.50 $3.25 77% U Ialdabode, Human Psion<br>DDM002059 $3.98 $5.13 78% U Small White Dragon<br>DDM003018 $3.25 $4.17 78% U Halfling Wizard<br>DDM005060 $1.52 $1.93 79% U Yuan-Ti Halfblood<br>DDM004019 $1.12 $1.42 79% U Lidda, Adventurer<br>DDM001001 $2.57 $3.16 81% U Cleric of Order<br>DDM001080 $5.13 $6.28 82% U Worg<br>DDM001030 $3.00 $3.62 83% U Wild Elf Barbarian<br>DDM001032 $4.15 $4.99 83% U Azer Raider<br>DDM001065 $2.34 $2.81 83% U Half-Orc Assassin<br>DDM001014 $2.94 $3.49 84% U Jozan, Cleric of Pelor<br>DDM003020 $4.35 $5.07 86% U Moon Elf Fighter<br>DDM001076 $3.58 $4.12 87% U Tiefling Captain<br>DDM001033 $3.00 $3.37 89% U Half-Orc Monk<br>DDM004062 $5.29 $5.92 89% UH Cloud Giant<br>DDM001011 $2.41 $2.69 90% U Sun Soul Initiate<br>DDM001031 $3.12 $3.48 90% U Wood Elf Skirmisher<br>DDM001072 $6.65 $7.39 90% U Orc Archer<br>DDM001062 $7.74 $8.48 91% U Drow Fighter<br>DDM001002 $2.62 $2.87 91% U Cleric of Yondalla<br>DDM001025 $4.28 $4.66 92% U Human Wanderer<br>DDM005034 $1.43 $1.55 92% U Half-Illithid Lizardfolk<br>DDM002027 $2.65 $2.85 93% U Druid of Obad-Hai<br>DDM001028 $2.93 $3.11 94% U Nebin, Gnome Illusionist<br>DDM005011 $1.19 $1.23 97% U Aasimar Favored Soul<br>DDM005013 $1.41 $1.45 97% U Bariaur Ranger<br>DDM001060 $7.85 $8.03 98% U Drow Archer<br>DDM005036 $1.31 $1.33 98% U Iron Cobra<br>DDM003050 $9.06 $8.79 103% U Drow Sergeant<br>DDM003017 $4.99 $4.68 107% U Halfling Ranger<br>DDM002058 $4.15 $3.75 111% U Red Samurai<br>DDM005014 $1.53 $1.31 117% U Cleric of Garl Glittergold<br>DDM002039 $3.31 $2.62 126% U Urthok the Vicious<br>DDM001035 $7.28 $5.72 127% U Lizardfolk<br>DDM003004 $5.71 $4.00 143% U Human Dragonslayer<br>DDM001079 $5.59 $3.83 146% U Werewolf<br>Uncommon $295.42 $477.92 62%<br>

Built the addition for this addiction, now on to the "gaming table" project.... http://www.maxminis.com/hw_list.asp?user=Zenako last updated 29 May 2006 Set Status: in a nutshell = all of all In Process trades0), (Sig last updated 05/29/06) 300 plus Completed Trades - If I seem scarce at times...blame DDO - Sarlona

kestrel.ca
Underboss

1676 Posts

05/18/2006 10:41 PM
quote: Originally posted by Zenako How about by Set <br> EBAY %<br> EBAY Madda of madda<br>HARBINGER $709 $1,085 65%<br>DRAGONEYE $293 $526 56%<br>ARCHFIENDS $542 $973 56%<br>GIANTS of LEG $492 $753 65%<br>ABERRATIONS $197 $364 54%<br> Curious as to whether the Ebay numbers are for the set as a lot, or the sum of the individual averages? And if not, how do those numbers compare? (Topic for another thread probably.) I'm assuming the Madda numbers are the sum of the individual averages.

Completed Trades/Transactions: 91 \|\| Pending Trades: 0 \|\| Bad Trades: 3 (Chaotic Good x2, MackeyV)

Zenako
Commander

3465 Posts

05/18/2006 11:23 PM
In this example the EBAY numbers are just the sum of the individual prices. I have data on EBAY Set prices and those look like this at my last data collection a couple of weeks back... <br>4/7/2006 19:38:00 PM<br> last 10 Average<br>Harbinger $621.55<br>DragonEye $300.46<br>ArchFiends $499.22<br>Giants of Legend $351.89<br>Aberrations $155.75<br>DeathKnell $179.66<br>AngelFire $174.89<br>Underdark $174.71<br>WarDrums $177.95<br>War of the Dragon Queen $0.00<br> so they are not that far off...kind of surprising in fact that there is such a small discount for buying entire sets compared to buying them as singles...

Built the addition for this addiction, now on to the "gaming table" project.... http://www.maxminis.com/hw_list.asp?user=Zenako last updated 29 May 2006 Set Status: in a nutshell = all of all In Process trades0), (Sig last updated 05/29/06) 300 plus Completed Trades - If I seem scarce at times...blame DDO - Sarlona

madda
Sergeant

714 Posts

05/19/2006 3:32 AM
Good information. There is no doubt ebay is much cheaper in general. I'd like to see the original post. Do you have a link ? When extending my tool to include ebay price harvesting I encountered many problems with excessive shipment costs to offset cheap miniature prices. Taking this into account can be daunting work. I'm considering adding some well known ebay shops (Auggie's shop for example) to the list. (No auctions, only buy now prices). This will no doubt give more accurate price estimation for in production minis.

Champion of Cockatrices. I wish I never wished a wand of wishing. (Wishful thinking.) Join the Eternal Campaign! Chat about miniatures.

Zenako
Commander

3465 Posts

05/19/2006 8:15 AM
Here is the link to his thread... http://boards1.wizards.com/showthread.php?t=620598 It really looks like he is doing it all manually, since there are so many unknowns about auctions that coding it up might be a real effort. Zenako

Built the addition for this addiction, now on to the "gaming table" project.... http://www.maxminis.com/hw_list.asp?user=Zenako last updated 29 May 2006 Set Status: in a nutshell = all of all In Process trades0), (Sig last updated 05/29/06) 300 plus Completed Trades - If I seem scarce at times...blame DDO - Sarlona

jgsugden
Commander

4320 Posts

Walnut Creek, CA

05/19/2006 12:51 PM
A few comments: 1) Thanks for all the hard work, Zenako. I did a bit of the same analysis (as we discussed), but I didn't have the time to go through the extreme efforts you did. Your dedication to the community is amazing. 2) The 'by set' prices on Ebay have consistently been around 60% (with a deviation around 4%) of the store prices in the price guide. If you're looking to buy by the set, the comparison between Ebay and store prices tends to be pretty reliable. This may be due, in part, to stores being one of the major purchasers of sets (which they then sell as singles). 3) I have been spot checking the Ebay/Price Guide comparison for singles for over a year. The results above are fairly representative of differences you'll be likely to find at any given point. However, as they are a snapshot of Ebay and OPG listed prices, they don't capture the dynamics of the situation. Ebay prices hop around like mad. Figures adopt an average Ebay price after release, but there are huge aberrations on either side fo that average. Whether you decide to include these outliers or not, you'll discover that the average Ebay price of the figures do not remain consistent. They rise and fall over time, often quite unpredictably. As evidenced by the Warbound Impaler, a figure can be almost worthless one month and then climb to the middle of the value range for a set within a few months. Whether these variations are reflections of actual market value changing rapidly or are merely aberrations is something that you'll have to consider for yourself. 4.) If you truly care about the market value of figures in a trade, the best thing to do is consider both the OPG and Ebay average sale prices. These are both measures that can provide some insight into the value of pieces, and both have strengths and weaknesses that are best when blended with the other. By considering both, you get a better picture. However, this is a lot of work... and it may not be worth the time you devote to save yourself a couple dollars worth of figure value in a trade. I strongly advise people to worry less about market value and more about personal value when making trades. Both parties should understand the relative market values of the pieces involved, but not making a trade that would make both people happy because the dollar figure value of the minis on one side is $65 and the dollar value of figures ont he other side is $63 is silly (IMHO).

Champion of Meepo __ Myztek on the Wizards Boards. __ (2206 DDM on 03/06/06) Please note: The use of the indicates an attempt at humor ... often a bad attempt. BAD EBAY SELLERS LIST (CLICK HERE): AVOID AT ALL COSTS

Zenako
Commander

3465 Posts

05/19/2006 1:44 PM
The lessons learned in my opinion are: 1) There is a pretty consistent relative value ratio between the pricing schemes. 55-65% pretty much covers the range 2) There is a large volitility on EBAY due to often much smaller sample size (plus the uncertainty of shipping costs in the average) so it REALLY pays to shop around if you are looking for a specific mini or two. 3) The best place to pick cheap commons is EBAY, even with shipping you will almost certainly save money. 4) EBAY sales are often not just single minis so the savings can be even more, IF you are in the right place at the right time, whereas the stores have the minis at a ~fixed price 24/7 available for purchase whenever you want them. That alone merits some of the price premimum. 5) No single source determines the value of a mini to someone. I would guess that I would be lucky to get most of my trades within about 10% value of each other on a side. So on a $200 trade, getting boths sides within $20 of each other was probably as much fine tuning as I used. Slavish devotion to "pennies" was and is foolish and using the info in ways that exceed its precision. (As a scientist I have a huge appreciation for using data within the limits of the significant digits. Just because that Instron Tensile Tester gives 6 digit readout on load, does not mean I should care at all about anything past the first 3 digits. The rest are meaningless system noise. (If those extra digits make a difference in pass/fail, then we have the wrong materials in the first place!!) 6) Based on the snapshot of data that KAGE collected and posted on WotC thread, I am going to revising downward slightly the ratio of 2/3 that I used to cite frequently to something closer to 60% on average over the range of sets. 7) My feelings are any changes in the EBAY data would probably offset other changes, that the overall answer remains about the same. Individual minis WILL change dramtically depending on which window of time you gather the data from, but that the population tendancies transcend the fluctuation of single minis. Zenako

Built the addition for this addiction, now on to the "gaming table" project.... http://www.maxminis.com/hw_list.asp?user=Zenako last updated 29 May 2006 Set Status: in a nutshell = all of all In Process trades0), (Sig last updated 05/29/06) 300 plus Completed Trades - If I seem scarce at times...blame DDO - Sarlona

KAGE
Sneak
Sneak

150 Posts

05/20/2006 12:53 AM
i've been super busy so I havn't been able to finnish the final sets. i'm hoping to do that this weekend. I thought about coding it, but I only know VB, and with all the unknowns is could be a bigger job then doing it manually. once i've completed the lists, I will start adding high's lows, ect. and trying to update each set once a month. nice comparison Zenako.

10000 days in the fire is long enough. You're going home... KAGE

Wraithborne
Commander

3517 Posts

West Virginia

05/20/2006 8:49 AM
Before adjusting down the percentage to expect from pieces, you may want to do another comparison after Madda's next Update. Paizo has drastically altered many of their prices since the Iuz saw the thread I started on the $35.00 Ambush Drake and the next price guide should show a significant change. The aforementioned Drake is now $14.00.

The year: 1994. From out of space comes a runaway planet, hurtling between the Earth and the Moon, unleashing cosmic destruction! Man's civilization is cast in ruin! Two thousand years later, Earth is reborn... A strange new world rises from the old: a world of savagery, super science, and sorcery. But one man bursts his bonds to fight for justice! With his companions Ookla the Mok and Princess Ariel, he pits his strength, his courage, and his fabulous Sunsword against the forces of evil. He is Thundarr, the Barbarian!

Zenako
Commander

3465 Posts

05/20/2006 9:31 AM
KAGE my programming expertise sucks, which is why I used to collect all the store data manually. Madda here developed the code to collect the data which is why I have gladly turned the price guide collection title over to him at this point. I know how much of a pain it would be to parse the data from the EBAY auctions. The the auctions where only a single model of a mini (with perhaps mutiples copies) is being sold is only a fraction of the auctions where you can get the mini. Do you count the ones selling 1 of each common from a set and devide by 12(or 16 or whatever as appropriate) and allocate the $4.08 evenly, or do you ignore the auction. Those types of questions are non-stop so I really do appreciate the effort required. I used to track EBAY sale prices of just the Rares back when we only had two sets (Herb, DragonEye), and that was a bit of a pain back then. As for the shifts in prices by a store. Happens all the time. And by large magnitudes like you just mentioned. Those shifts get smoothed out when averaging the data over a dozen plus stores, especially when the mini is still fairly available. The real outliers stick out when only a couple of sites have a mini available and the high price is not tempered as much. (Example using the Drake as a case in point: Prices in my last data collection 8.99 $8.95 8.99 9.95 $8.00 6.99 $10.00 $12.00 $8.99 9.99 9.49 $4.99 Average $8.94 Median $8.99 Now drop in one $35 instead of the $10 for example and the average changes a bit, but probably not enough for anyone to notice as being a big issue. Average $11.03 Median $8.99 So the influence of one outlier on the overall pricing is very minor, in absolute terms, which is also why I believe that changes in individual minis will have minor affects on the overall values. Population averages when gathered from a large enough sample base tend to change very slowly.

Built the addition for this addiction, now on to the "gaming table" project.... http://www.maxminis.com/hw_list.asp?user=Zenako last updated 29 May 2006 Set Status: in a nutshell = all of all In Process trades0), (Sig last updated 05/29/06) 300 plus Completed Trades - If I seem scarce at times...blame DDO - Sarlona

kestrel.ca
Underboss

1676 Posts

05/20/2006 10:35 AM
quote: Originally posted by Zenako <br>4/7/2006 19:38:00 PM<br> last 10 Average<br>Harbinger $621.55<br>DragonEye $300.46<br>ArchFiends $499.22<br>Giants of Legend $351.89<br>Aberrations $155.75<br>DeathKnell $179.66<br>AngelFire $174.89<br>Underdark $174.71<br>WarDrums $177.95<br>War of the Dragon Queen $0.00<br> Thanks for the info! quote: so they are not that far off...kind of surprising in fact that there is such a small discount for buying entire sets compared to buying them as singles... Or, in the case of Dragoneye, it's better to buy them as singles. [:)]

Completed Trades/Transactions: 91 \|\| Pending Trades: 0 \|\| Bad Trades: 3 (Chaotic Good x2, MackeyV)

madda
Sergeant

714 Posts

05/20/2006 1:03 PM
quote: Originally posted by Wraithborne Before adjusting down the percentage to expect from pieces, you may want to do another comparison after Madda's next Update. Paizo has drastically altered many of their prices since the Iuz saw the thread I started on the $35.00 Ambush Drake and the next price guide should show a significant change. The aforementioned Drake is now $14.00. I updated the price list, but I don't think there's a real change overall. Changes in just one shop are small in the big picture. I didn't look into the data, however. I just finished a long DMing session, and I'm dead tired. One more thing, I have a framework for ebay price mining, but it's not as robust since I don't run it daily or check it at all these days. It can be revived. The major problem is the fact that the sales history is very short (at least when I login) and provides a very little sample if any. Other problems are multiple quantities sales (which the script should analyze but it's not tested) and greatly varying shipping rates. One can argue that shipment cost should matter for online shops as well, but it's less frequent to put high shipment costs and low miniatures costs in shops.

Champion of Cockatrices. I wish I never wished a wand of wishing. (Wishful thinking.) Join the Eternal Campaign! Chat about miniatures.

madda
Sergeant

714 Posts

05/21/2006 7:46 AM
Guys, Since I already have an ebay tool, I let it ran tonight (it takes forever to do all the queries). I'm using my own user when signing in ebay so the history is very limited (I have a simple account). The format is very similar to the auto price list format (they use the same tool). Instead of number of shops, the list shows number of transactions. Edit: The data was removed as there's a newer summary below. A few more notes : * Only automated tests were done. I didn't validate any of the data. * The search pattern for the advance search is: D&D . So missing transactions are possible. * When having the phrase "x10" or "X 4", or simply "[xX] " (as regular expression) the code divides the price by that number to get the price of a single. This counts however as one deal. The search is for completed transactions only, and includes BIN items. * Shipment cost is not included in the price. Hope this helps.

Champion of Cockatrices. I wish I never wished a wand of wishing. (Wishful thinking.) Join the Eternal Campaign! Chat about miniatures.

Gnolaum
Sergeant

854 Posts

05/21/2006 7:24 PM
quote: Originally posted by madda DDM002022 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 0 U Kerwyn, Human Rogue DDM003019 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 0 U Ialdabode, Human Psion DDM003021 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 0 U Ragnara, Psychic Warrior DDM004058 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 0 R Red Dragon Wyrmling Ahhh, the unloved.

My online store http://store.hoardsters.com Use quick search to see scans of every stat card!

Zenako
Commander

3465 Posts

05/22/2006 10:29 AM
On a quick scan over it, I did not spot anything that looked too broken as far as prices. Unless you upgrade accounts you are limited to about a 2 week window of completed sales. Does your code limit the completed auctions to certain keywords in the auction title? Or does it just mine the whole world of completed auctions? I come across a few auctions with only the mini name, such as Umber Hulk, in the listing and there is nothing about D&D, or Harbinger, or Miniatures in the title. This may be too small a subset to worry about, but they are out there. I also agree that EBAY shipping is much more variable and generally expensive than store shipping on a per mini basis. Most EBAY sellers are looking to recoup all ther fees in the shipping and "handling" charge that they levy. This is usually offset by lower auction prices in the first place which in my mind accounts for a portion of the price delta that is observed. I will take your recent data and see how it compares to the stuff KAGE had compiled and see how consistent the numbers are from period to period. Thanks. There is a small fraction of us DDM'ers who enjoy this sort of number analysis and trend plotting...while many others enjoy the fruits of our obsessions...

Built the addition for this addiction, now on to the "gaming table" project.... http://www.maxminis.com/hw_list.asp?user=Zenako last updated 29 May 2006 Set Status: in a nutshell = all of all In Process trades