Below is a compiled list of problem trades taken from the old ‘disputed trades’ threads. It is to serve as a general reference on outstanding problem trades. If your name appears on the list below, it does not necessarily mean you are considered a ‘bad trader’. This list only states that you have at least 1 trade in dispute with another member.

If you have a disputed trade, post on this thread and I'll add it to the list. Please do not email me to report a dispute.  It's much better to have the problem out in the open rather than explained only to me.

Disputes are listed in alphabetical order by trader name. The traders the disputes are with are also listed in alphabetical order. Quotes are taken from what Zenako had listed on the trade data list.

Trades that have been acknowledged as resolved will be eliminated from this list. When a disputed trade is successfully resolved, it is important that you let the community know on the disputed trades thread!

Please keep the level of discussion on this thread to a miniumum. The purpose of this thread is to report factual trade disputes with other members. If you want to discuss the situation further, please feel free to do so on another thread (without making personal attacks). I recommend posting a link to discussion threads here to help other members follow the situation. I will regularly delete extraneous posts from this thread.

Finally, Please Note: There are many Maxminis members with similar ID names and this has led to some confusion. Please check carefully. For instance, MackeyJ (no disputed trades) and MackeyV (many disputed trades) are different people.

Disputed Trades as of 6/16/08

 

Disputed Trader:          ÂComplaint filed by:

2manyfigs/the babblingbard (same user)         grnblk95, jeremiahcarissa, Kat_Dawg33, Wolffenjugend(9/27), Myth Master Jr(9/27)

 

alexgrondin               Âkyrin

 

Allard                       Âgausse, Ghendar (5/30/06), Ironfist Boulderbender (5/30/06)

Anaxagoras                 area71(5/28/08), dumdragon(5/29/08)

Basic_Aim aka SteelPred aka ImprovedCleave on Wizards      Wraithborne (01/04/08)  

BattleMaster              dj-chuckles(10/21), Sir Bozak The Damned(02/08 ),
 

BigFON                   Âjscifert

 

BigME                     ÂIdzy

Biggpoppa001            Werebat(2/03/08)
 

bshugg                     ÂEric is God

 

Cha0tic G0od            arksorn, bonelock, bugsy, ChristopherGroves, Dahak, dj-chuckles, dpoppink, Drakul, Dropbear, frostrune, gausse, galneweinhaw, gregreid, Grey One, jai, johnboy069, johnny_gaijin, Kaya Kenobi, Kelvezu, kestral.ca x2, Kiv, kritter, Kypdurron, Link, Marjorie x2, Oni, PatEllis15, qillan_dvra, Red Ranger, sheleski, Siddartha of Suburbia, Tysac x2, Warflail, Zardnaar

BEWARE CG is AKA Resurrection, Do Urden, Dead Man Walking, Wraith, Tactician, Incarnum, Dungeons N Dragons Gamer, Minis for Minis and  possibly more. Based on recent evidence posted by LCS  the id "SLJ" may be another one.

 

Chairman Klench      ÂNixlord (trade missing cards, non-responsive)

 

Clay                         �?? "some concerns"

 

Counterzero42         ÂDarkfather

 

Cragger                    Âjai

 

Dead_radish            ÂWhyte Angel (this may be resolved)

 

Dead Man Walking  ÂDead Man Walking is a known alias of Cha0tic G0od

 

Deckten                   ÂDarkfather (disputed for >2years)

 

dndonuts                   Gausse(10/02)

Do Urden            ÂDo Urden is likely an alias for Cha0tic G0od

Dj-Chuckles              Jeremiahcarissa(9/26)
 

Dragonhorde25       Âsmetzger, tallcar24

 

DrakoonHarmToucher  qillan_dvra(10/26)

Drakkar_Templar     ÂDenise_rpga

 

Dred_Lord               ÂArdus

 

Dungeons N Dragons Gamer   ÂDungeons N Dragons Gamer is likely an alias for Cha0tic G0od

 

Fellintooblivion          Âdfoos, maximus_, Mikl, SgtStriker

Geka                         Âqillan_dvra

 

Hawksmoor              ÂJayster5

 

Hellfire2                    ÂDarkfather

 

I Kill For A Dollar    ÂCha0tic G0od, Diomedes (Apparantly someone named "Christian" stole his userID)

 

Incarnum                  ÂYukon Cornelius Incarnum is likely an alias for Cha0tic G0od

 

Irkahn                      ÂArchimagus, Skyscrapper

 

IronfistBoulderbender   kreatobergas, torazin(10/25)

 

itaintnothing               ÂKithmaker

 

Jake108                    Âvesvius

 

Jawa Jedi / Wampa / Bith Rebel          Âasteroidjawa

 

Jell-O                        Âgausse

jeremiahcarissa        Corim Danex, Krush, sterling40(11/07)
 

Jester                        �?? "suspect trader"

 

JESTERGYPSY       ÂKAGE

 

JFORCE74              ÂSean-Khan

 

John Krajeski           ÂGolth, Smith568

 

Jubei555                  ÂA Can of the Cave Beer, Ares71

 

Juice_valley              Âcavedweller, Thatoneguy

KONG                     �?? "bad trader"

 

Litorian                        Planchet

lyus_sleyden          chrisman321(01/16/07)


MackeyV  akaÂgatts      Albrecht, Cha0tic G0od, demagague, Fragadar the Wise, Hugo, Kreatobergas, Marjorie, striker

Mickey Mouse         sfgiants(10/13/07)

mickeychraal aka Dirge Inferno (on UKDDM)    theotherguy (6/9/08)

 

Madchildswollen         ???

 

mattjuarez                    jlynch

 

me_is_fred                ÂFeathers,  lyus_sleyden(3/14/06), Venport, Ironfist Boulderbender(03/19)

Minis for Minis                  Yet another alias for Cha0tic G0od    

Mixmaster                 ÂSammael

 

Mister Unfortunate    ÂThousandsofminis (5/15/06)

 

m0nj0mb0                Âdm5, scallamander

 

Moonshot                 �?? "some issues"

 

Mouley                    ÂCha0tic G0od, Dreamwither, phillipjp

nasamonkey               simage, rtcmc(11/15)

Okay Mckay            ÂKithmaker

 

Olrak                       Âaussie_jim

 

Orion311                Â"issues with", Tev

 

pesti69                     Âarbados(4/7/06)

 

Pexeterblue1            ÂArdus, BigBC, lseelba

 

Pitchman205            ÂDarthCharger, Drconveyor, lingster, Marjorie

 

Puffer                       Âcamp0243 (5/15/06)

Resurrection                      Resurrection is an alias for Cha0tic G0od.
 

Roland Deschain      ÂLance

 

Rogueslaw               Âmattjuarez

sardal failed to send first  Wolfgang(04/17)
 

Satsujin Kingyo          arbados

 

SgtStriker                ÂMark-of-chaos, thenameless

 

Son of Cyric            ÂCorim Danex

 

Steel Pred               ÂOryan77

 

Sweetwater D         ÂN/A (JWilder?)

 

Tactician             ÂTactician is likely an alias for Cha0tic G0od

 

Tattoo                      Mjspawn, thenameless

 

Tabbas                   ÂNeolis, Nixlord

 

TechNoMercy        ÂAlterEgo, Bonelock, Darthrau, King O Vrock

 

Thayil/Datapwat        Arbados, ares71, Oyvind, Pan, thedip, Zeb

Thrace                     TLorin

Thor                         Kritter(11/25) {package partially rec'd-trade still disputed as of 12/16}

Tichondrius            ÂKithmaker

 

tree druid                Âjedijon(3/13/06)

trillistria                     shoesan
 

Uk                         ÂDNDJUNKIE

 

Van Hoo III             Dr.Cornelius, greyhaze, lowlevelstatic, TigersClaw

varez/drizzt -same user  aka Drizz't Drow Lord                       Kezghan(9/19), gmblk95(9/19), Wolfgang (?) jeremiahcarissa(9/26), lyus_sleyden (9/29), wheeljack(10/06), qillan_dvra(11/13), Sir Bozak The Damned(02/08 )
 

Wraith                   Âserithax, Sir Bozak The Damned

Wraith is an known alias for Cha0tic G0od

 

Wolfmoonspel           ???

Yotebeth               Shottglazz(12/10)

CG/Dead Man Walking/Whoever he might be now UPDATE

No communication with CG since early November. He seems to have vanished once again. Guess I shouldn't have expected anything.

On 11/17 Dragonhorde25 sent me a trade proposal of my Roper and Dreagloth for his Iron Golem and Thri-Kreen Barbarian. On 11/27 he updated the trade to say he had shipped his end. So on 11/29, I shipped mine using the post office. My DC # is 0305 2200 0001 2291 4531. According to usps.com it arrived on 12/3. I have not received anything from him and he has not responded to any of my emails.

tallcar24

quote:

---

Originally posted by spikegif

as asked in another thread.....

Still no package from dj-chuckles.

---

Package received [:)]

I really hate to do this, but it looks like my trade with Litorian is a wash. We agreed to a trade late last month, and I sent my end on Nov 22. I've gotten no response to the few emails I sent him, and he's completely dropped from the IRC Dragonlance game he's been running for more than year. Should I hear anything from him, I'll be sure to update the thread.

This is the first of two complaints:

Wraith and I agreed to a simul-ship deal back on November 22rd. I shipped the next day and he said he did the same. He checked that he received on December 22nd and did not even leave a feedback on the interface. I still do not possess his minis, while he has my Marut and probably sold it for 20$ US on eBay...

As to emails, he only answered me once out of at least 5 times and did not even offer to check if he could find any information. I was robbed :(

I would like to list a disputed trade with Wraith.

We agreed to a trade on the 11th of Dec. I shipped on the 12th and he claimed he did also but he did not include a DC# which I specifically asked him to. On the 21st, after an email asking for a DC# again, he replied about the package being crushed in the mail and returned and that he would send it back out. Again I requested a DC# the next day and again 5 days ago. Still no package and no response from him. He did however make an ebay purchase off of me in that time frame through Wraithchampion Superstore.

Here is a link to Ironfist Boulderbender's reference thread, on which are recorded details of my disputed trade with him:

http://www.maxminis.com/forums/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=425

I have had a long outstanding trade with Allen Turley (Ironfist Boulderbender) for what might be a year or longer. Anyways, just yesterday I received an email from him stating that he would like to rectify our outstanding trade! I had lsited him as a bad trader and I know others also have outstanding trades with him as well. He has informed me that he is trying to make right on all his trades and has told me that on Tuesday he will be sending me out all the owed minis as well as a bunch of repaints/promos to make up for the problem.

I asked what had happened and he said it was due to some medical bills and also just not having all the stuff. I guess a screw-up on his end.

Anyway, I will keep you posted as to if this gets rectified. I had been scammed by 3 people and over the last few months 1 has fixed the problem and now 1 more might actually come through and send me minis to compensate for what I thought was a lost trade.

Yes, I understand that it doesn't make things completely right, but at least they are trying to fix the problem. It is better than me never getting the minis.

Just wanted all to know. I am sure Kong will never come through and rectify his trade.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Sir Bozak The Damned

This is definitely a safety issue maxmini should cover or at least ban his IPs and anyone that seems to remotely be the same **** ! [:(!]

---

That is one of the silliest things i have heard of. Banning an IP is a pointless exercise, and good luck finding a reason why 'maxminis' should be responsible for an error in judgment or just plain bad luck.

While i am here, i need to report that Cragger has gone MIA. I sent him a figure in return for some custom clear figures he was making. It was an informal trade, but a trade. His last visit was the 13th and he hasn't returned. I don't want to say anything bad, but over a month is easily enough time for me to be upset. I have no problems (it is possible he is still on vacation or winter break) at the moment, but at least want to post something.

I have an ongoing trade with BigFON (Jason Collins). The trade is:

My:

BigFON (1/5/2006): [Counter Offer]
1x Warpriest of Hextor (R)
1x Phoelarch (R)
1x Mina, Dark Cleric (R)
1x Dwarf Wizard (U)

For his:

1x Zombie White Dragon (R)
1x Orc Archer (U) - No card (maxi does not allow for status with minis)
1x Worg (U)
1x Kapak Draconian (U)
2x Winter Wolf (U) - due to lack of card on Archer

I sent my miniatures out over 2 weeks ago and have not heard a response from Jason that he received my miniatures. I have not received anything from his end of the trade, despite REPEATED e-mails to update me on the status.

If this trade resolves, I will update this thread accordingly.

God luck and happy trades to all!

quote:

---

Originally posted by jscifert

I have an ongoing trade with BigFON (Jason Collins). The trade is:

My:

BigFON (1/5/2006): [Counter Offer]
1x Warpriest of Hextor (R)
1x Phoelarch (R)
1x Mina, Dark Cleric (R)
1x Dwarf Wizard (U)

For his:

1x Zombie White Dragon (R)
1x Orc Archer (U) - No card (maxi does not allow for status with minis)
1x Worg (U)
1x Kapak Draconian (U)
2x Winter Wolf (U) - due to lack of card on Archer

I sent my miniatures out over 2 weeks ago and have not heard a response from Jason that he received my miniatures. I have not received anything from his end of the trade, despite REPEATED e-mails to update me on the status.

If this trade resolves, I will update this thread accordingly.

God luck and happy trades to all!

---

**********************************************************************

Others have replied to this thread as well in another posting under trading references thread:

kritter
Knight Captain

Canada
916 Posts

Posted - 01/19/2006 : 11:49:10 AM View Have/Want List View Trades View Refernce List Show Profile Email Poster Reply with Quote
well would have to say the same thing, i started a trade with him

Initiated: 1/1/2006 (kritter)
Accepted: 1/1/2006 (BigFON)
Shipped: 1/2/2006 (kritter)
1/7/2006 (BigFON)

not only did he take 5 days to mail the trade, it took 3 emails to get a response from him to see if he sent. now its been 18 days since i mailed my end and still no response from him to tell me if he recieved or not.

the lack of communication is quite alarming, i have sent 3 more emails and got no response yet.


Trades: Complete:77 Ongoing:5 BAD:1 = Cha0tic g0od

Champion of the Aspect of Yeenoghu, Demon Prince of Gnolls
Go to Top of Page

Nixlord
Knight Marshal



Philippines
2042 Posts

Posted - 01/19/2006 : 1:34:33 PM View Have/Want List View Trades View Refernce List Show Profile Email Poster Send Nixlord a Yahoo! Message Reply with Quote
Oh boy, I hope he just mailed late.

He has a good track record at the Wizards boards and he has made a couple of good trades here as well.

But if he did try to pull something like Tabbas did before, I would have lost another big trade ($160 worth of minis).

I hope he pulls through.

PENDING TRADES (9):Shakespeare, Darthpoke, Bassman2972, Sir Bozak the Damned, BigFon, griffrat, Arksorn, Strachan Fireblade, Runelord151

| My References (131 Completed Trades) | New Trade System List | My Haves/Wants List | Email me |
Go to Top of Page

Lab Monkey
Knight Warlord



USA
3011 Posts

Posted - 01/19/2006 : 1:40:28 PM View Have/Want List View Trades View Refernce List Show Profile Email Poster Reply with Quote
Would you please repost this in the Disputed Trades Thread?

Thanks,
LM
Have: Cat; Want: Storm Giant
Champion of Anything Dragonlance
Go to Top of Page

I also have what might be a problem trade wth BigFON. I have not received my mini yet, nor have I heard from him in over 2 weeks. Please list this as a problem trade until it is resolved.

Sigh,
JIM
aka kyrin

Problem transaction with Anaxagoras. Agreed to purchase minis on December 13, 2005. No payment as of January 20, 2006. Not responding to email.

i recieved from BigFon so please remove my name from his entry ... i still haven't heard from him to see if he recieved my package

OK, another week has gone by with no sign of minis and no communication whatsoever (despite my continued efforts), so I'm going to declare my current trade with Mixmaster bad. I hope that it'll get resolved soon. I sent the minis on December 28th, at the same time as another trade (which was successfully concluded last week).

Trade with Ironfist Boulderbender has been resolved, and I am very satisfied with the results. Please remove my name from his list of disputed trades.

smilinIrish posted here
http://www.maxminis.com/forums/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=425&whichpage=2
that he received from Ironfist Boulderbender. I think this means their disputed trade is resolved.

It has been a few weeks, and I have not received my end of the trade from BigFON, nor have I received any communication from him. Please list our trade as Disputed.

Thanks,
JIM
aka kyrin

Ironfist Boulder bender has made good on his outstanding trade with me. My name can be removed from this list of those who have outstanding trades with him.

godemperor is trading again
http://www.maxminis.com/forums/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=14513

Two complaints against him

Wow, I've never felt this relieved in a long time when a large package containing 160$+ worth of figs finally arrived. [:D]

It was definitely from BigFON, but strangely enough there was no return address on the package.

I'm happy though that he came through. Whew. Thank you.

I hope that's good news for the other guys (kyrin, etc.) who are still waiting from him.

quote:

---

Originally posted by jai

While i am here, i need to report that Cragger has gone MIA. I sent him a figure in return for some custom clear figures he was making. It was an informal trade, but a trade. His last visit was the 13th and he hasn't returned. I don't want to say anything bad, but over a month is easily enough time for me to be upset. I have no problems (it is possible he is still on vacation or winter break) at the moment, but at least want to post something.

---

I have heard from Cragger via email. He is down on his luck, and wishes to return once he has resolved his personal issues. He is paranoid to return for fear of being branded, and i suppose it is a valid fear as we don't like those we "brand" as thieves. He offered to send back my mini so as not to rip me off. I am making a deal with him that he sends back my Large Fire as a sign of good faith. When he settles things and return, i will be able to vouch for him, and then i will send the Large Fire back to him so that we may continue our trade arrangement. I will post again when i have recieved.

quote:

---

Originally posted by nyjastul69

GodEmperor has posted in his trade thread that he is attempting to rectify things.

http://www.maxminis.com/forums/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=14575

---

I've not received an email from him. I'm not sure how he can compensate at this late date - our issue was a VERY long time ago ... Archfiends-days.

Yeah I did and he responded. Here's the deal...

* I told him to let me know what he thinks should happen.

* Being on the disputed trades list doesn't make you an evil person ... nor does it indicate INTENT of the person to make a bad trade. Shipping problems, live, etc. can interrupt to make a trade (not trader) go bad ... and thus the list.

* I have no problem with him trading here; I do think folks should be cautious and ask him to send first possibly.

* I don't think he's a scammer, just a guy that had a rough period.

quote:

---

Originally posted by spikegif

for those who have disputed trades with MackeyV, has he contacted you about completing his end yet?

---

He hasn't contacted me since March 2005 i sent in January 2005 and have yet to recieve!

Well, according to the thread he's resending the missing item(s) to thenameless from their trade. He was supposed to send me (in July of 2004 ... that's right 18 months ago) Displacer Beast x2, Bright Naga, Lion Falcon Monk, Gnome Recruit x3. I'm not entirely certain he has two DBeasts and an LFM he can trade anymore.

Not sure how it will fall out, however it does look like there is some movement.

Chaotic good sends
> > >
> > >LRD
> > >Cleric Corellon
> > >Halfling veteran x4
> > >Alusair
> > >Lion Falcon Monk
> > >Young Master
> > >HEBI
> > >Daring Rogue
> > >
> > >Kyle sends
> > >
> > >Owl Bear
> > >Hound Archon
> > >Bone Devil
> > >Dire Wolf
> > >Nighwalker x2
> > >Treant
I sent in January 05
i NEVER GOT A THING The most upsetting part of it is that i was defending him on the boards, as i thought he was being straight up with me. Made a fool of me didn't he!

I sent an e-mail to Van Hoo III 2 days ago (After 25-30 emails sent), and received an e-mail. He wanted my address to ship the mini. I sent him my address and will let you know what happens.

BigFON here,

I screwed up on my last round of trades and have left several people hanging. I apologize to NixLord, Kryin, Kritter and jscifert for the extended lack of communication and the delays in these deals. I found NixLords missing Death Sladd card and am mailing it, along with Kryin and jscifert's packages tommorrow via Airmail and 2-3 day priority mail. I have contacted them and sent the traking information for the packages. I have no excuses, just screwed up on this round of trading. I also would like to apologize to the community at large as there is enough bad mojo as it is.

Respectfully,

Jason Collins